TREAT HIM WITH CHARITY

Eugene, aware of the pain experienced by the Oblate community in Corsica because of the behavior of Leopold Carles, (which we saw in a previous entry) wrote to its superior.

In this world, one must expect everything, my most dear Father Semeria. There is nothing more scandalous than the defection of the unfortunate Carles, but nothing less surprising in the light of the pitiable behavior he has always maintained. I am going to decide his case immediately, but I am writing to you beforehand to ease your pain. I am enclosing in this letter the one I am sending this unfortunate man; read it before giving it to him. I approved the conduct that you followed in regard to him. Independently of his bad dispositions, his disobedience merited this sentence…

Try to cover up the scandal as much as you can; treat him with charity, but do not let yourself be outdone. You have nothing to reproach yourself for, the evil dates from far back. It is a great misfortune that Masters of Novices are not informed enough and allow themselves to be fooled.

Letter to Father Etienne Semeria, 25 July 1844, EO X n 850

Eugene and the local community had done their best to help him, but to no avail. “Treat him with charity” was the advice to them in dealing with him in the remaining days he would be with them.

This entry was posted in WRITINGS. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to TREAT HIM WITH CHARITY

  1. Eleanor Rabnett, Oblate Associate says:

    Sometimes we can tend to forget that these men, then (and now) were only human, they were not perfect in spite of the courage and heroism of their lives. Like the apostles, they had both strengths and weaknesses. Like Judas, some have betrayed themselves and those they served.

    I can only imagine what it is like for Fr. Semeria, Eugene and any other of the Oblates who were aware of what was happening with Leopold Carles, whether they knew the reason or not. Did they feel a sense of betrayal? It can sometimes take great self-determination and self perseverance to treat the one(s) who has betrayed us with love, with charity.

    Eugene, then and now, seemed to be aware to what was happening with those he loved, a result of his own sense of being betrayed himself in during the years of 1832 to 1835. It was love and forgiveness that healed his wounds. Eugene knew that love as the only thing that could heal certain wounds. His love is evident in his letter to Etienne Semeria for it is filled with compassion and consolation: “my most dear Father Semeria… I am writing to you beforehand to ease your pain.”

    Anger and even hatred can step in and fill the void left by betrayal and it’s resulting pain and loss, making love and forgiveness the only way to experience any lasting healing. Eugene knew that it would take nothing less than charity to assuage or soothe the hearts of the Oblates at the loss of one they have loved. “Father forgive them for they know not what they do.” (Luke 23:34)

    Is this not how we are all trying to live now and I am thining of those of us who have experienced a recent betrayal of our fellow Canadians? It is love that will bring about forgiveness and healing, within ourselves and those who have hurt us.

    “Charity, charity, charity…”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *